Biblical
Counseling and the Prosperity Gospel:
The
Same Side of the Same Coin.
It might sound odd at first to hear
that Biblical Counseling and the Prosperity Gospel share the same premise. This statement must be patently absurd! After all, those places most noted for
Biblical Counseling are bastions of reformed thought that vie relentlessly
against the encroachment of the Prosperity Gospel.[1] Yet, despite this apparent divergence, the
Prosperity Gospel is alive and well being actively propagated by these
schools. No, you will not hear John
MacArthur saying things like a health and wealth preacher, but you will find
Biblical Counseling being actively promoted.
Before going further, it is
appropriate to define what I mean by Biblical Counseling. The Biblical Counseling Coalition says on
their website, that God
“comprehensively addresses the sin and suffering of all people in all
situations.” This of course is done in
Scripture. This clearly means that Biblical
Counseling is founded upon the use of Scripture. A second point to this is that Biblical
counseling does not rely upon psychology because “When systems of thought and
practice claim to prescribe a cure for the human condition, they compete with
Christ (Colossians 2:1-15). Scripture alone teaches a perspective and way of
looking at life by which we can think biblically about and critically evaluate
information and actions from any source (Colossians 2:2-10; 2 Timothy
3:16-17).” Biblical counseling in a
nutshell is the use of the Bible centered on Christ to address the problems of
the “whole” person. (To be clear,
psychotherapy seeks to help a person in their distress, and does not
claim to prescribe a cure for the human condition this definition is overtly polemical at his
point.)
How then can such an obviously good
thing centered on the Bible, Jesus, and helping people be compared in
qualitative manner with the Prosperity Gospel?
Simply put, they make the similar claims about similar aspects of life. It is not difficult to find Prosperity Gospel
speakers equate physical suffering and financial difficulties with sinful
behavior (which is often gussied up under the term “lack of
faith/trust/belief”). God will bless
those who trust in Him in a demonstrable manner. And to be honest there are Bible passages
which can be used to support this.
Biblical Counseling makes that claim that by dealing with sin and
exercising demonstrable faith in the Word of God that God will bring mental and
emotional health. In both cases, the
thing that separates you from the blessings of God is your sin and a lack of
repentance. Likewise both promise that
once that faith is enacted God will act to bring the state of blessing into
one’s life. The only serious difference
is that Biblical Counseling posits that it can take a long time to bring this
change, while the prosperity peoples typically do not offer very long time
frames.
Just as the Prosperity Gospel can
lead people to ignore medical advice from Doctors and defy economic common
sense, so also Biblical counseling leads people to ignore the right use of
doctrine and the collected wisdom of the field of psychology.[2] Although Biblical Counseling is touted as
truly operating upon the doctrine of the Sufficiency of Scripture, it offers a
distorted Gospel from a distorted doctrine.
The doctrine of the Sufficiency of Scripture was used to speak about how
Scripture contains those things which are necessary for salvation and that
these same things are clearly seen from Scripture. Therefore Scripture is sufficient for one to
know what one must do to be saved. This
is evident in the Westminster confession, which I have previous argued is
incorrect on this point.[3] Yet, what was once a doctrine of Scripture
speaking about salvation has now been used as a means of rejecting
psychology! The Bible does have quite a lot to say
about how our souls can be healed by God.
However, it is not a manual of how to heal mental disorders nor was it
written as a post-enlightenment psychotherapeutic manual despite its
insights. Attempts to force the Bible
into this paradigm are guilty of fundamentally misusing the Bible and forcing
it to address things that it did not directly address.[4]
In a move befitting the
fundamentalist caricature, the “Sufficiency of Scripture” is being used to
support a worldview that does not need to accommodate the learning of any field
outside of Biblical Scholarship (which itself must be treated with abject
horror if it does not conclude within the proper confessional boundaries). Mental illnesses are cured through exegesis
and repentance. This might be more of a classical
Fundamentalist attempt to regain influence in a sphere (counseling) while
eschewing the principles of counseling. I speculate that this goes back to a perceived
need for authority and clear answers, which (from its perspective) are
primarily found in the Bible (but only when interpreted in a particular way
within a particular confessional model).
The Biblical Counseling movement
offers the same answer for mental health as the Prosperity Gospel does for
physical health and financial soundness.
Trust Jesus and He will provide.
Neither of these assertions fits with reality. Historically, there have been many who have
been very faithful Christians who suffered from various physical and financial
difficulties (the Apostle Paul comes to mind).
In the same way, there have been many Christians (and even saints)[5] who have experienced
mental illness perhaps even without healing.
There is even a category for this in Russia Fool-for-Christ. Further, John Cassian and other monastic
authors frequently engage with topics of mental and emotional health in direct
relation to living the monastic life and being aware of one’s own soul and body.[6] These issues were not new topics that emerged
in the 1960’s, but there is a long Christian tradition that addresses many of
the same things today, but in a manner quite distinct from the Biblical
Counseling movement.
It is important to note that
Biblical counseling affirms a good thing in affirming the need for
repentance. Indeed, the life of a
Christian is a life of repentance. The problem
comes when there are mental/emotional/relational problems that cannot be solved
through my repentance. Rape, abuse,
bullying, etc… leave damage upon the victims that cannot be healed through
repentance alone. This is the ultimate
failure of Biblical Counseling. It
cannot address the wounds on a soul wounded by another’s sin.
[1]
Based upon
the sound advice of my wife, no schools are named herein.
[2] There are a couple of evidence
based psychological theories which are largely ignored by Biblical counseling
(possibly because they do not fit the polemical bent of the movement). For example, see: Attachment Theory.
[4] Anecdotally, my first encounter
with Biblical Counseling was when I visited a friend and went with him to his
counseling class. I was horrified by how
the Bible was being used. Proverbs
7:21-23 was used as an example of how the Bible speaks to the alcoholic. Contextually, this is speaking about the
adulteress woman who is the counter-part to Wisdom:
“With much seductive speech she persuades him; with her smooth talk she
compels him. All at once he follows her,
as an ox goes to the slaughter, or as a stag is caught fast till an arrow
pierces its liver; as a bird rushes into a snare; he does not know that it will
cost him his life.”
Apparently arrow and liver along with the invitation to
drink were all that was required to clearly demonstrate how this addressed the
alcoholic. Because otherwise, I would
have understood this to teach me about resisting temptation and the dangers of
self-gratification to my soul and body.
In defense of the prof who taught this, when confronted,
he said that it seemed a little odd to him and that he would revise his lesson
for the next time he taught the class.
[5] I am not going to attempt to
retroactively diagnose anyone. Such
attempts are utter folly and go against the very nature of professional
behavior in the fields of counseling and history.
[6] Here is a link to John Cassian’s work the
Institutes. Note his section on the
spirit of dejection.